Nurlan

I like Koshienko works, but it is good idea to put reference if the basic idea is used too much

the question is too broad, and unfortunately, it is next to impossible to provide an adequate answer. But I can give an example of plagiarism. Tanya Grotter by Emech, he completely uded the main idea of Potteriada about tough ub-ringing, arch-enemy and so on in order to create his universe and the conflict. In the work of Koshienko I see the same. His idea is based on idea of plagiarizing music and other staff of authors unknown in this new universe. Moreover, this conflict between the super-intelligence girl  and the society is also quite similar to ideas from I am a  really superstar. So. in my point of view, the base was stolen, some details were added ( probably,in order to add Russian colorit, and his target audience is Russian people), and we have what we have))) I like the author work, but if you take too much without reference of source, it is below the belt and the sigh of plagiarism 

I think it is a very shallow and superficial view on this situation. Between time traveling and this book is a world of difference. But from your side, any imaginary staff is the same. You can live in your world, but for me, using knowledge of physics and chemistry is a little bit different from using other people songs in order to fill your pocket. But I admit, the general topic is intellectual property. Although for any person with a little of thinking ability, it is crystal clear the case of plagiarism 

Sorry< You should have studied better at school. English is an international language

idea of transferring in the new world originates from Chronicles of Narnia. But idea of transferring in the same world but without many artists, and got money from plagiarism??? I think it is better to ask the author wheather or not he used this score of information (Chinese novel) 

I think, nowadays, everyone should at least be able to read in English. I am sorry for you bro.. YOU should have studied more at school(((

to be honest,"I am a really superstar" is also a light novel with everyday update. it is difficult to find the original date of the first publication ( i dont know Chinese), but I saw 2013 year in some Chinese cite. From my view, it is quite unlikely that a Chinese gay  can understand Russian and plagiarize. On the other hand, English translation of " I am a really superstar" is available since 2014. And I think, Koshienko can read English. In the end, It is a case of plagiarism, at least the building idea of Shkurki.

From my point of view, the plot has been stagnating. Of cause, the books are derivative and not original (The idea was stolen from the Chinese novel "I want to be a super-star"), but I cannot see any kind of personal development.  Even with authors inclusions of different characters perspectives, the plot is too much straightforward. It became boring. Instead of good literature, I got quite shallow work, with little though-promoting ideas. 

Мне кажествно, что произведение данного автора вторично, т.к. основные идеи характера персонажа взяты из серии о легендарном лунном скульпторе. Идея мира(структура) взята из Хризалиды. Стоит отметить, что навыки автора улучшились по сравнению с первой книгой. Жалко, что сюжет линеен (боевка. навыки и т.д) очень мало сюжетных линий. Видимо, target audience is teenagers with low-brain activity for them it would be next to impossible to follow convoluted plot. Учитывая все вышеперечисленное, вряд ли автор получит премию Хьюго.